Nobel Laureate Roger Penrose on the Nature of Consciousness

Roger Penrose is a great physicist and mathematician who has contributed much to our understanding of the nature of consciousness, especially with his theory connecting quantum mechanics with the functioning of the brain. His ideas run against mainstream scientific thinking and offer a more profound and complex relationship between the mind and the physical world. Here's a summary of his key thoughts on consciousness:

The "Orchestrated Objective Reduction" (Orch-OR) Theory

In collaboration with anesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff, Penrose developed the Orch-OR theory, wherein he proposed that quantum processes inside neurons of the brain gave rise to consciousness. The theory postulates that microtubules, part of the cell structure involved in maintaining cell shape and intracellular transport of molecules, are capable of supporting quantum states. According to Penrose, it is in these microtubules that quantum computations take place, quantum computations being essential in the experience of consciousness.

The main idea here is that the emergence of consciousness doesn't arise solely out of the action of the classical brain but out of a quantum activity in the brain, reaching some threshold and collapsing-just like a quantum wavefunction in quantum mechanics collapses. This collapse, which Penrose speaks of, is what he refers to as objective reduction (OR). According to this view, when a quantum superposition reaches some critical level of instability, it collapses spontaneously, which, in turn, is linked with conscious awareness.

The Problem of Consciousness

The approach of Penrose is based on his "hard problem of consciousness", a problem dealing with how and why some brain processes are associated with the generation of subjective experience. According to Penrose, classical physics cannot explain this phenomenon of consciousness because it also tries to explain the qualitative, subjective aspects of mind referred to as "qualia." Contrary to this, in ordinary physical processes-which we are trying to describe objectively in terms of clearly defined causes and effects-consciousness has been a seeming mystery apparently unable to be captured by classical physics.

For Penrose, it is precisely this non-algorithmic nature of the mind that is the key. He famously argued in his book The Emperor's New Mind (1989) that human consciousness cannot be reduced to simple computational processes or formal algorithms. This is going to imply that the human mind is not just a highly sophisticated computer but is likely to be engaged with something more profound, possibly quantum in nature.

Quantum Mechanics and the Mind

Penrose draws on the mysteries of quantum mechanics, particularly the wavefunction collapse, for an explanation of consciousness. According to classical physics, a system  is in a state of probability until it is measured. Penrose speculates that a similar quantum process might be occurring in the brain and that these quantum effects could give rise to conscious experience.

He is also interested in how gravitational effects could interact with quantum mechanics at the smallest scales. The view of Penrose challenges the classical one, in which the brain is considered an object purely classical-operating in a deterministic and algorithmic way-and suggests that quantum mechanics may influence neural functioning in ways not yet understood.

The Role of Quantum Gravity

The famous thinker, Penrose, has long been interested in the unification of quantum mechanics and general relativity-two theories that form the two pillars of modern physics in describing subatomic and cosmic phenomena, respectively. He speculates that quantum gravity effects may arise from combining those theories, thereby shedding light on consciousness. According to the Orch-OR view put forward by Penrose, he says that gravitational forces could cause the collapse of a wavefunction in the brain; it is this that he bases his explanation of conscious awareness on.

In the book The Road to Reality, 2004, Penrose shows how quantum effects could be working at a much more serious level than that which we can presently fathom, with the suggestion that consciousness may be part of the universe - not only related to the brain but also to the underlying texture of reality itself.

Cosmology and Consciousness

He even advanced to suggest such a relationship between quantum processes in the brain and the nature of consciousness, connected with the cosmos. In a way, he has examined the idea of the non-algorithmic texture of the universe on the cosmological scale-the fabric itself-perhaps connected to how the human mind works.

This is related to his cyclic cosmological model, CCC, wherein he postulates that the universe undergoes infinite cycles, each beginning with a Big Bang. Penrose speculates that the structure of spacetime and the quantum processes that govern the cosmos may also underlie consciousness, suggesting a deep, cosmic link between mind and universe.

Criticism and Debate

While groundbreaking, his ideas have also generated significant controversy. Detractors note that the processes of the quantum brain that Penrose describes are quite speculative and do not have a very strong basis regarding empirical evidence for the existence of quantum effects in the brain. Others propose that consciousness can perhaps be explained thoroughly by classical processes, or even completely new ones, using neuroscience and psychology. Penrose's highly controversial theory did stir some rather interesting debates relating physics, consciousness, and reality.

-----------

Penrose has contributed to a deep understanding of the nature of consciousness through the opening up of a serious dialogue between quantum physics and philosophy of mind. In his theory, Orch-OR offers an intriguing glimpse into how quantum phenomena could conceivably play a central role in consciousness. Whether this eventually proves to be correct or not, Penrose has moved along the idea that the mind is far more deeply connected with the most fundamental laws of the Universe than we perhaps have ever before imagined.